S
SeaMaiden
Am I the only person here who still remembers recording radio shows and editing out the music I wanted? Reel-to-reel? Cassette tapes? Whatever happened to Fair Use laws?
Did you ever record a movie from TV onto VHS and keep it?those file sharers are stealing after all,those movies are someones property just like your house and the stuff inside it...
Stealing is stealing. I'm sure the people ripping off people's plants this time of year justify it some how.
stealing the hard work of an artist so that the label can make 90% profit, is wrong. me nabbing an album and taking $0.30 from the artist is almost negligible, when i spend $60+ going to their shows. you're damn right i'll steal it from the label because they didn't do shit but put a stamp on it, and then reap the rewards of the artists hard work. granted they can put the cd in more stores, but that doesn't mean it'll sell. if it wasn't for sharing, i wouldn't have ever even heard of 1/2 the bands i listen to, go to see, or buy the merchandise i do now.
think about bands that don't get radio play. where does their money come from? it's usually not from cd sales, but from touring and merchandise sales at those events. take iron maiden for example, in the u.s. they have NEVER gotten radio play, thus their niche is greatly reduced here, as well as their marketability. if it wasn't for the fans sharing their love of the band, they wouldn't have sold 85 million records worldwide without tv or radio support. it's the over 2000 shows worldwide, and word of mouth that has kept them at the top of the metal scene since 1978. same could be said for metallica, and many others that didn't/don't get commercial airplay.
Impossible!
Theft equals the unlawful removal of goods or services without permission. By making a copy, you are not denying anyone of their lawful property or time. Therefore copyright infringement is just that, copyright infringement, not theft.
To be guilty of copyright infringement you must first deny the owner of a profit that they otherwise would have made should you not have taken the action. If this was made law, then they would also have to charge sony etc. with conspiracy. These manufacturers make the machinery that is designed exclusively to record programs from the tv, music from the radio etc. Can you actually see them trying to put these companies out of business? Removing all dvrs from the shelves?
In short, all you would have to do is claim that you weren't stealing from them, you were performing a favour for them. You were advertising their work on their behalf in order to try to increase awareness of the product in the market place. This in turn does not detract from their profits, but increases them Unless you were charging for the product and making profits in their place, it would be extremely difficult to challenge that in court.
not to get off track but metallica gets alot of raido airplay since like 2000 granted in 87 they got none......Maiden started getting a little bit of raido airplay around 89-90 with "can I play with madness" from seventh son of a sevent son cd....And I would bet my balls that Bruce is a pirate and believes in free sharing........The artist never gets the proceeds from free sharing but they also get raped and molested on their share of the proceeds from legit sales...I don't think anyone here will argue that the artist should benifit over the corporation.I believe whole heartedly in supporting an artists work that you enjoy...We do this by as said above going to concerts and buying merch.or by going to the movies and most of us do from time to time and pay those ridiculous prices of admission.