I have been running a led grow for a few years now. Initially, led was rejected in the US market because all the cheap one watt one spectrum Chinese assemblies hit and proved to be quite disappointing. These lights as well as the early UFO 90watt lights were quite useful for veg. uses such as clones and seedlings, but not so for flowering applications.
Thus, LEDs were quickly rejected by experienced/knowledgeable growers in favor of traditional mh/hps set-ups.
But for some, LEDs were just too attractive to simply walk away from. The promise of greatly reduced heat output and less costly electric bills just kept calling me back. I also stuck with my then state-of-the-art 90watt UFO's, and began to gain knowledge and experience.
To my surprise I was able to get some fine finished buds of Himalayan Gold which I'd been growing from Greenhouse Seeds stock. Now, I won't claim these buds equalled ones grown under a 1000watt lamp, but they were more than decent. And this was achieved using 4 90watt units in series. With one watt diode. BUT they were multi-spectrum units. In 2010 this meant 6 spectrums.
Thereafter I moved into the advanced led line, purchasing their diamond series 880watt 11 spectrum unit. I set it up as per directions and independent study. Such a powerful light has to be about 20-30 inches distant from the plants, or they will experience a sort of light bleaching effect. Also, some buds can become "burned", which upon magnified examination, presents clearly as " unnatural bursts" of many pistils cramming in & out where the light is too close and intense. So, clearly, I was dealing with a far more powerful yet subtle light source than I had ever used indoors. And in thirty-plus years of indoor growing, that is a lot of systems!
In any event, current LED technology has arrived. There are several great companies out there, and the smaller 200-400 watt units are what I use in 3x3 spaces. The canopy penetration is excellent with all my units, and even the 300watt has to be at least 8-12 inches distant from the plants to avoid too much brightness.
Yes, the LED lights are a considerable investment, and no one should feel they're a must have. Traditional lighting of all kinds work great in thousands of situations. And I personally think CFLs are still the best, most economic means of just growing plants. They are cheap, easily available, And get the job done in veg.
But 4 years into my LED explorations, I will never use traditional lighting again but by necessity in flowering chambers. LED produces the best indoor bud I've ever grown, hands down. As close to outdoor as I've ever seen, smelt, tasted & handled. In both my organic soil & NFT hydro grows, it beats out my 1000's & 400's. That's it. Game over. I hated to pack them up after all those years, but it was clear.
The plants flower faster and fuller.All the strains (8) really finished richly and full of fragrance. Resin production is always excellent. Some strains finished up to two weeks ahead of my traditional lights, most seem to finish on the predicted schedules.Depending on strain characteristics, bud densities were virtually equal to outdoor results.
In summation, if you can afford the cost and time to explore LED lighting, I endorse them without reservation. Look at all the companies and options out there. There are a lot now and every month seems to bring new developments and products. And seriously, for most personal grow applications, the smaller wattage units coming out are the cheapest yet and work great. Hopes this helps someone out there. I will post a few photos on another post of actual results.
Listen, I would like to (and can) make the investment in LEDs, monetarily but right now, with no credible proof of production (that I have seen), I do not want to toss the $$$s invested in ballasts and bulbs and the time, to 'give LEDs a go'.
I've seen little documented proof of your (and others) claims of, = HID production with like power lights. I'll wait for those pics. maybe some other than those blue/purple pics I've seen from LED grows. grows from beginning to end.