What's new
  • Happy Birthday ICMag! Been 20 years since Gypsy Nirvana created the forum! We are celebrating with a 4/20 Giveaway and by launching a new Patreon tier called "420club". You can read more here.
  • Important notice: ICMag's T.O.U. has been updated. Please review it here. For your convenience, it is also available in the main forum menu, under 'Quick Links"!

Whats this look like?

Robm4n

Member
Whats this look like to you guys? cal def.?



there on vegging plants starting from bottom working up


gallery_76_20_17192.jpg



gallery_76_20_36892.jpg
 

trichrider

Kiss My Ring
Veteran
looks like....thrips or worse...mites.
examine the underside of leaf for tiny black spots or tiny white egg-looking insurgent, possibly in conjunction with webs.

if this is a deficiency/lockout, I don't know what it could be.

good luck.
 

vostok

Active member
Veteran
Look close there is a patten here, not bugs, ..as its to patten-sh, mid to late nute burn if in soil flush with 3 times the volume of the pot, allow to recover overnight or 1x day in dim light

if in DWC, dump the rez...clean well, reload, but cut back the nutes by 33%..upping 10% every 24 hours ..monitor closely

Of more concern is the faded leaf veins to me an early indication of (Mg) def(deficiency)
on the last flush, add 1 teaspoon of cal-mag or Epsom salts to the rinse, or go foilar with 1 x teaspoon to a pint hand sprayer fill with warm water shake well and spray 2-3 times per day for 1 week or until you see it clears ...
good luck
 

papaduc

Active member
Veteran
It's definitely not nute burn, mag deficiency, or thrips.

Don't flush your plants because it can weaken them and if it is a fungus or deficiency that'll only make things worse.

It looks like leaf spot fungus to me.

What are you feeding them?

Any pictures of the whole plant?
 

vostok

Active member
Veteran
Rather than start a flaming war with the membership ...

How about you impart more info on your crop ...

like medium, lights and your experience..?

etc etc
 

Robm4n

Member
i'll get full plant pics up in a bit but there in promix, being fed Dyna gro grow, ph going in is 6.0 there under a 400 hps, all the plants arent showing this just a few the ones sitting next to them are fine, they are diff strains, seems to be starting low, when i look at the leaf i see rust spots, i have been growing for years but have never been good at diagnosing deficiencies and what not, i appreciate everyones help.
 

br26

Active member
Miracle Meds said it, Calcium. Ca/Mg works

usually promix has adequate lime for Ca.
 

BigBozat

Member
Rather than start a flaming war with the membership ...

How about you impart more info on your crop ...

like medium, lights and your experience..?

etc etc


Kinda looks like effects of wild pH fluctuations (and maybe cal or manganese)... but Vos is right: more pics of whole pant, more details of your grow b4 flame war breaks out, lol :laughing:
 

Miraculous Meds

Well-known member
i'll check my runoff tonight when i flush, but i dont have a EC /ppm meter

Don't worry about the ppm meter. U wanna check ph most, anyway. What this problem in general looks like to me is calcium is being locked out because of too much magnesium. Not because ur nutrients r off or u need more. Im sure they are adequate. Just when ph is high it makes mg more available, and that causes poor absorption of calcium. It happens to me in coco when my ph swings high. Don't add more ca or ca/mg, cause it will just exasperate the problem. The trick is to adjust the ph so calcium becomes available.

The other thing people goof up in this situation is to add lime, thinking they need more calcium. All that will do is double ur problem, cause now u have added more ca, throwing off ur ratios of nutrients, and also raising ph even more, locking out ca even worse.
 

papaduc

Active member
Veteran
What this problem in general looks like to me is calcium is being locked out because of too much magnesium. when ph is high it makes mg more available, and that causes poor absorption of calcium.

I'm pretty sure calcium and magnesium are available through the same ranges. Calcium deficiency isn't as common as people think. If you're feeding a balanced nutrient with calcium in it, you shouldn't see one.

Whole plant pictures under normal light would be good.
 

Miraculous Meds

Well-known member
I'm pretty sure calcium and magnesium are available through the same ranges. Calcium deficiency isn't as common as people think. If you're feeding a balanced nutrient with calcium in it, you shouldn't see one.

Whole plant pictures under normal light would be good.

Higher ph allows more availability of mg. the now high available mg locks out the ca, making it deficient.
 

BigBozat

Member
I'm pretty sure calcium and magnesium are available through the same ranges. Calcium deficiency isn't as common as people think. If you're feeding a balanced nutrient with calcium in it, you shouldn't see one.

Whole plant pictures under normal light would be good.

Higher ph allows more availability of mg. the now high available mg locks out the ca, making it deficient.

My understanding was that papa's right about Ca & Mg being similarly avail thru the same pH ranges... in soil...

... but that in hydro, MM's right... they run at diff ranges (Cal more avail below 6, Mg more avail above 6), such that at higher pH Mg can lock out Cal...

:2cents:
 

papaduc

Active member
Veteran
Higher ph allows more availability of mg. the now high available mg locks out the ca, making it deficient.

Like Bozat said, in soil they're both available at higher ph range. The soil will buffer the water anyway, so a properly buffered compost shouldn't need it's water phing. That's what I was told when I grew in compost years ago, not to ph adjust your water. Everything I've ever grown in compost I've never once PH checked or adjusted and I've never had a problem feeding 7.4 tap water as long as the feeds are right. I think if something's being locked out by a a bad ph then it's where the buffer's set in the compost rather than the ph of the water going in. That's to the best of my knowledge anyway.
 

Latest posts

Latest posts

Top