bs0
Active member
you left out one critical element..
you see joe gets the 28,500 "prebated spending"
cutting his 18% down to about 7%
AND
he gets to keep his entire paycheck instead of lending it to uncle sam..
allowing him to actually build savings.
now in your scenario joe makes 50 loans uncle sam 5 and spends 45 to live.
joe don't get to save...
way to keep the poor from ever getting ahead...
To account for the 'credit', just keep scaling it. If 'oprah' from my example makes 3 million, she now would be paying less tax than your 'joe'.