What's new

Turbogarden (Ebb & Flow) vs. Econojet(not 2x2) vs. Waterfarm

Turbogarden (Ebb & Flow) vs. Econojet(not 2x2) vs. Waterfarm

  • Botanicare Turbogarden(Ebb & Flow)

    Votes: 21 36.8%
  • Botanicare Econojet(not 2x2)

    Votes: 13 22.8%
  • General Hydroponcs Waterfarm 8 Pack

    Votes: 23 40.4%

  • Total voters
    57

311

Member
am thinking of ordering 1 of these systems. I have been hittin the web several hours a day, looking for good prices on these systems, and have found lower than average prices, from some Hydroponic stores. So I am torn between the
1)Botanicare Turbogarden Ebb & Flow, that normally goes for $325, my local store sells it for $380 plus tax(another $25). I found it for $240, and it is the complete system too(not like I need hydroton, or nutes, but I never used Botanicare nutes(aside from Cal-Mag+, Sweet and Clearex, which I have in my gear now), but hey I can try it, and regardless. I saw a Bare bone(no medium, nutes, etc. And it's still $50 more expensive then this 1 I found. So I think it would make sense to get the bigger bang for my buck.

2)Botanicare Econojet. Now there's 4 of these systems, though the most popular is a 2x2 system. There is also a 2x4, a 3x3, and a 4x4(is NOT an option. 2 big). now the 3x3 is pretty expensive because of shipping, where the 2x4 system is cheaper by a few dollars and shipping is regular(not special shipping like 3x3) so it's cheaper also. So anyways. I can get a 2x4 system for about $250, and a 3x3 from about $300-$325, shipped to my house. Oh yeah, and those prices are w/o the bench. Figured I really don't need to pay that much for a stand. That I can make right?

3)Then there's the General Hydroponics Waterfarm 8 pack. This one is iffy. Because I hear that it's a lot of maintenance. Plus I use General Hydroponcs Floralicious+, and though it's made by GH, I have had people tell me that Drip Systems are BITCHES when it comes to feeding(tubes clogging and such). It has to be certain nutes/supplements. Some nutes/supplements don't work as well in drip, as it would as per say in Ebb & Flow. I'm not trying to say that there's nutes just for Drip System. But from my understanding, not all products work as well in drip systems. Please correct me if I'm wrong. I have never used ANY of these systems. I have grown 4 times in DWC system, and this is my first time in soil/soilless(and I HATE it!) I need to go back to Hydro, but don't ever want to do DWC again. And I don't want anymore DIY. I want to try a "real" system.



So check it out...... ALL INPUT ARE WELCOME BUT!!!!! I REALLY want to hear from the people who OWN, or HAVE OWNED.

Oh yeah!!!!! Another thing I wanted opinions on. If the choice were the Turbogarden, or the Econojet. Should I use 5" pots, in a ebb and flow or just fill the tray with hydroton? Just scared if I use containers that light will hit that nute solution.
 

311

Member
Sorry..... Had to turn my notifications on, and had to test to make sure it worked. It's on now, and I'm waiting for peoples opinions. Thanks.:xmasnut:
 

Craven_au

Active member
Sorry man i can't help you with the Botanicare Turbogarden and Botanicare Econojet have never done ebb&flow or flood and drain is that the same shit.The Turbogarden look like it could do a nice sog. I do like the look of the Waterfarm nice and big you would need 2 1000w or 2 600 at least.
I can say that drip system do use a shit load of nutrients conpared to dwc. I have never had any problems with my diy drip system like tubes clogging just maybe over feeding, i would go back to a nice rdwc system with a big res tho. And i dont like aero just to many things can go wrong. I do like NFT have u seen SCROGERMAN grow.
http://www.icmag.com/ic/showthread.php?t=148001
 

Bobby Stainless

"Ill let you try my Wu-Tang style"
Veteran
I have a 8 site WF, and they are a bit of a hassle, if you don't have your nutes dialed in. I pick the res up every day, and elevate it for an hour to mix all the buckets up.
picture.php
 

turbo14

Active member
Veteran
Look at my name... Turbo Gardens are Super easy and very well built! It really comes down to how many plants you are wanting to have. I run 4 Turbogardens in a 4x8 Homebox XXL with 3 600w and have fantastik results:) I usually veg for around 7-10 days with HEAVY LST..

my .02
Turbo
 

Bulldog11

Active member
Veteran
I like both the Turbogarden and the Econojet. I voted for the Econojet because it looks easier to change out the nutes without the tray sitting on the res. I have tried all kinds of different systems and Ebb and Flow has worked the best for me over time. Simple and easy, nothing complicated about it. Good luck to you.
 

311

Member
I will reply to ALL of u individually.... But I must show respect 1st and THANK ALL OF U! I posted this poll on 2 other sites, and have not gotten ANY responses. ICMAG is my #1 source of info now. ALL U GUYS WERE FAST WITH RESPONSES AND POLITE. I will spread some rep to ALL that has responded to me. U guys ARE AWESOME! Thanks once again, and keep the responses coming. I'm loving it! Peace, Love, Unity, and Respect!
 

turbo14

Active member
Veteran
I will reply to ALL of u individually.... But I must show respect 1st and THANK ALL OF U! I posted this poll on 2 other sites, and have not gotten ANY responses. ICMAG is my #1 source of info now. ALL U GUYS WERE FAST WITH RESPONSES AND POLITE. I will spread some rep to ALL that has responded to me. U guys ARE AWESOME! Thanks once again, and keep the responses coming. I'm loving it! Peace, Love, Unity, and Respect!


Happy Growing Brotha:canabis:

turbo
 

311

Member
Sorry man i can't help you with the Botanicare Turbogarden and Botanicare Econojet have never done ebb&flow or flood and drain is that the same shit.The Turbogarden look like it could do a nice sog. I do like the look of the Waterfarm nice and big you would need 2 1000w or 2 600 at least.
I can say that drip system do use a shit load of nutrients conpared to dwc. I have never had any problems with my diy drip system like tubes clogging just maybe over feeding, i would go back to a nice rdwc system with a big res tho. And i dont like aero just to many things can go wrong. I do like NFT have u seen SCROGERMAN grow.
http://www.icmag.com/ic/showthread.php?t=148001
Dude thanks soooooo much for coming thru, and helping. I hope the info Igave u about the DM nutes helps. DM is VERY strong, so be VERY careful. I must admit, that though it's been a BIG pain in the ass with this soilless soil grow, the buds taste a lot better:smokeit:
As far as DWC, I can't ever do it again. 5 grows, and ALL except 1 had issues with roots. The only way that 1 time that the roots stayed beautiful, was me pumping SOOOO much col air in the room. I had to keep the room at 65 degrees f so the res would stay at 67-68, that way my nutes(I use a couple of organic supplements) would not go bad. as long as that res stayed under 70 degrees, I had no issues, once the res hit 70of, my roots would turn color, and start getting mushy. It was a DIY bubbler, and it was light proof. I took a 5 gallon bucket, and covered it in aluminum tape. So no light leak. NFT do look good, but I heard can be a pain in the ass also. By the way, SCROGERMAN's grow is SICK! +rep for the help, bro!
 

turbo14

Active member
Veteran
I also forgot to say, if using Turbogardens...I suggest getting the lid that is optional with the 14 - 5.5" round holes pre-cut, In my opinion this lids accompanied by suspended net cups do waay better than the 5.5" square pots...Great System.

turbo
 

311

Member
I have a 8 site WF, and they are a bit of a hassle, if you don't have your nutes dialed in. I pick the res up every day, and elevate it for an hour to mix all the buckets up.
picture.php
YEAH BOOOOOOY! Dude thanks for the advice! So I'm assuming ur against the Waterfarm, even though u got 1. That's the response that is important. People have said that the main issues with the WF has been tube clogging AND because not all the nute solution makes it back to the res, it sits in the buckets, and can cause havoc, with ur plants. So that is why I'm assuming u shake ur buckets, is to move that stagnant nute solution. Right? Love ur space though dude. U got a perfect room size, in the basement I'm assuming. I 2 will have my basement soon, hopefully!:window:Are u using 2 1000 watts, and how far are u keeping ur lamps away from ur girls? Just wondering cause the lamps do look high up. And I use 1-600 watt air-cooled reflector, along with 1-400 non air cooled, and my temp of the canopy hits 79, but that's with 3 fans blowing over canopy. I'm 18-26" away from the bulbs(depends wat part of the canopy, obviously) Thanks for all ur info, bro. +rep. Peace, Love, Unity, Respect.
 

311

Member
Look at my name... Turbo Gardens are Super easy and very well built! It really comes down to how many plants you are wanting to have. I run 4 Turbogardens in a 4x8 Homebox XXL with 3 600w and have fantastik results:) I usually veg for around 7-10 days with HEAVY LST..

my .02
Turbo
LMAO!!!!!! Ok I will look at ur name, BUT!!!!! IT says Turbo 14?????? Does 14 stand for age??????? JUST KIDDIN MY BROTHER! I am stuck on the Turbogarden, and it is the 1 that I really wanted BUT!!! U said it brother,m when us said it depends on "How many plants" After reading a lot about it. It seems most growers using it, ALL said it was perfect for SOG. How many plants do u get in 1 tray? When u say u veg for 7-10 days, r u saying clones? If so do u start counting veg, after the roots have shown, or as soon as roots are forming do u transfer to Turbogarden? Or are u growing from seed, and 7 days after the first true leaves come in, u transfer to Turbogarden. Also wat does HEAVY LST mean? Thanks for ur response, brother! Peace, Love, Unity, and Respect!
 

311

Member
I like both the Turbogarden and the Econojet. I voted for the Econojet because it looks easier to change out the nutes without the tray sitting on the res. I have tried all kinds of different systems and Ebb and Flow has worked the best for me over time. Simple and easy, nothing complicated about it. Good luck to you.
ANOTHER + about the econojet..... Plus the fact that the trays are a nice size. If they made a Turbogarden, with a 2x4 or 3x3 tray, I would not have even started this thread:2cents::smoke:. My only issues with the Turbogarden, is 1-the tray size, 2- is the fact that I'm being told that the tray IS the cover to the res. Is that true, people? I would rater have a proper lid to the res. Just makes me think that res with a proper lid is more reliable, IMO. But all and all, the Ebb & Flow seems to be the way +rep. Thank bro. Peace, Love, Unity, & Respect.
 

311

Member
Sorry man i can't help you with the Botanicare Turbogarden and Botanicare Econojet have never done ebb&flow or flood and drain is that the same shit.The Turbogarden look like it could do a nice sog. I do like the look of the Waterfarm nice and big you would need 2 1000w or 2 600 at least.
I can say that drip system do use a shit load of nutrients conpared to dwc. I have never had any problems with my diy drip system like tubes clogging just maybe over feeding, i would go back to a nice rdwc system with a big res tho. And i dont like aero just to many things can go wrong. I do like NFT have u seen SCROGERMAN grow.
http://www.icmag.com/ic/showthread.php?t=148001
Oh yeah, that DIY system looked pretty pro to me brother. U did a GREAT job with it.
 
You could easily and cheaply put a recirculation kit on the water farm setup and fix the nute mix and stagnation issues. I hate having to poke the white junk out of the drip tubes on the water farms, I used to have take the whole ring and tube apart until I discovered you can just chase a wire down the air tube and clear the obstruction.
 

311

Member
Oh yeah, another thing that I would like to know is, if I go with the Ebb & Flow, do u guys recommend using Containers or just fill the table with hydroton. If I use containers, when the table floods, will it not cause light to hit the nute solution, causing algae? and tell me if anyone agrees with this. I have a bunch of tubes and feeders, so I was thinking of startin on the tray with feeding tubes, and once the roots are showin, or at the end of vegging(not sure yet), and then filling the tray with hydroton(or using containers). Thanks guys for ALL the help!
 

311

Member
You could easily and cheaply put a recirculation kit on the water farm setup and fix the nute mix and stagnation issues. I hate having to poke the white junk out of the drip tubes on the water farms, I used to have take the whole ring and tube apart until I discovered you can just chase a wire down the air tube and clear the obstruction.
Ive actually heard of people adding an air stone to each of their buckets(not sure if that's wat u meant). And I never thought of using a sturdy metal wire. Will keep that in mind! +rep. Thanks. Peace, Love, Unity, & Respect!
 

311

Member
This poll is turning out GREAT! I'm telling u I have started this same EXACT thread on 2 other sites, and have only gotten 1 response on each site. And on 1 of the responses the person asks how many plants I'm trying to grow, then replies that he uses soil, and has never used those systems. And the voting is going no where. Seems like u guys are really trying to help! THANKS AGAIN MY BROTHERS AND SISTERS!
 

311

Member
I just wanted u guys to see the response I finally got from someone over at a different website. I wonder why there is SO much arguing on those sites.... Ready.....

Originally Posted byxxxxxxxx
You can easilly make any of those systems for a fraction of the price just by going to lowes. Thats why no one is giving input, we don't waste money on overpriced plastic buckets and fittings.


I love how he claims no one is "helping" me because apparently I'm wasting HIS/THEIR money I guess for him to be SOOOO f@#$in concerned on wasted money. How rude is that post??? Or am I the A-hole?
 

311

Member
Look at my name... Turbo Gardens are Super easy and very well built! It really comes down to how many plants you are wanting to have. I run 4 Turbogardens in a 4x8 Homebox XXL with 3 600w and have fantastik results:) I usually veg for around 7-10 days with HEAVY LST..

my .02
Turbo
By the way so I don't look stupid... I'm assuming 14 in Turbo14 stands for the fact that the Turbogarden is a 14 site system.:tree:Mom school paid for something. I do have a brain! LMFAO!
 
Top