They sure assume a LOT as FACT...and not "theory". Actually...it's ALL theory...and very LITTLE actual fact.
I usually spend more time laughing as they keep going on and on with pure imagination...all the time acting so sure of themselves, like they're right there looking at it in real time.
they're good shows but if you don't know other theories, you're left to believe that it's the ONLY thing scientists believe. Same with all those "science and nature" shows...full of conjecture.
Could not agree more, they started throwing out crazy shit so long ago, and people ate it up so shit like this is on TV and accepted as fact, it used to be funny but now its absurd / sad.
I watched the life of a star thing, it was cool but so much was obviously an extreme stretch.
Wow...some people are buzz kills...just let people enjoy what they want to, who cares if you personally believe it or not...
What kind of attitude IS that? "Just let people believe whatever they want"? Doesn't matter whether or not it's true...it's entertaining???
This is why we have these "heated" discussions here...there are a WHOLE LOT of misinformed people...misinformed because they watch shows like this...AND the nightly news. They think they "know" something because those master authority figures the TV or the government or a university told them it was so.
IF you watch it ONLY because of the pretty pictures...AND you approach it as "someones imagination"...fiction...then I"m OK with the general public...and kids...watching it. It IS after all...just the latest "best guess".
Just as we laugh at what people believed throughout history...people WILL laugh at YOU someday for what you believed.
We're not at the top yet...we don't know it all...not by a long shot.
Don't get me wrong...I love these shows...but I also know the producer has an agenda...I know to keep an open mind. It's just another opinion. It's not "the truth". It COULD be someday...but we don't know yet.
The National Science Foundation and all the other supporters of these types of shows are in it for the money. They hope that these programs will lead to more government/corporate research money for the science industry that they represent. Politics...EVERYTHING runs by it...it makes the world go round. Want the "why" of anything...follow the money/power trail.
I like the ghandi quote, I had a birthday card with that on it.
I'd love to burn a phatty with Carl Sagan while atop Mauna Kea and wax theoretics. The night sky always put me in my place, and reminds me that the earth is part of the heavens...
Religion for some, is based on faith, that is not knowing but believing. Those beliefs can be what control you or set you free.
Ps... Albert E, explained how gravity works (though newton said it pulls, AB said it pushes) and these shows demonstrate with cool graphics the physics behind it.
Science, physics and wonder all have a place in this world, the next and all the pionts of light in between.
it's like everything else - don't swallow ANYTHING whole!! chew it on the way in...
btw if you lose your buzz on the universe, just go outside on a clear night with binoculars and a tripod.
space is 3D - not some pinpricks in a canopy. if you look at it long enough and hold your mouth just right, suddenly you see that 3D effect and it is wonderfully disorenting. no up or down in space!!
but... there is NO nebula as close to earth as that picture shows...
If people want to watch it for the pretty visuals what is it to you? Not every thread needs someone to "educate" them or enlighten" them, nor do politics need to be involved in everything. You take things a bit too seriously...relax, live and let live...You totally misinterpreted what I originally said, btw.