[5cooby Doo]

I have a 4x8 tent and odour control will be really important. As far as a carbon scrubber goes, does a larger filter mean more odour filteration? I am looking to buy a Phresh 12", MountainAir 12" or Can Max 2500CFM Filter. Would this be adequate? I used a chinese air filter before and it did not work well.

Thanks!

[Speed of green]

thats complete overkill.



for standard overkill you should be looking in the 750cfm range with a comparable 750 cfm 8" fan.

mountain air is a good brand, just make sure you duct everything properly, zero smell issues.

to arrive at this number you find the volume of your tent so 4x8x7= 224cuft

if you are not using air conditioning then rule of thumb is 2x air exchange per minute so 448 cfm, plus resistance from lights or additional ducting & the carbon filter itself. the 750cfm will leave you happy, you can get a fan speed controller if you dont want it running full blast the whole time.

good luck!

[5cooby Doo]

Hello Speed of green

Overkill is not bad is it, if I have a big scrubber, but run the inline on it closer to their minimum cfm rating?

No A/c. It will be a passive intake.

The only reason I am hesitant is because that other filter was the same size as those I mentioned (except it was an off-brand), and the last two weeks of flower, when I would open the door to my home, it was like getting punched in the face by Floyd Mayweather multiple times.

So I should be safe if I choose a better brand yes, then I don't need to go so much over kill?

[Vanilla Phoenix]

I flower in a 5 x 9 x 7 tent using a 8" Vortex fan and a Can Lite 8" filter (the larger 8" one). And there is absolutely no smell outside of the tent.

https://growershouse.com/can-lite-ca...-inch-1000-cfm

[5cooby Doo]

Vanilla, are you using a passive intake?

I saw the Can-Lite to, but read some people saying it was not quite as effective as the original can? Although it seems to be working fine with your build.

Although there is no smell outside of your tent, how bad is odour from the exhaust? Or is that basically gone when it goes through the scrubber as well?

[repuk]

overkill can be bad, no doubt about it.

- If you exchange more air than needed, your plants will live on a wind-tunnel, RH/VPD will be out of range and impossible to control. As has been pointed out two air exchanges per minute should be your goal as max.

- Scrubber has to be properly sized and matched for the selected fan, so that air is pulled through at the pressure ("load") the filter was designed to work at.

[Vanilla Phoenix]

The way I have mine set up is I only have one exhaust fan, the 8" Vortex (747 cfm). The air is sucked thru the 2 air cooled reflectors. I actually blow into my scrubber instead of sucking thru it. Ideally you want to suck thru it but they work either way.

So...passive intake thru bottom--->air cooled reflectors--->Fan--->Can Lite--->out

Or you can go....passive intake thru bottom--->Can Lite--->Fan--->air cooled reflector--->out

I suppose to be on the safe side, you could get the original Can Filter to be safe. To be honset, I have 8 plants in my flower tent all one week apart in age. So I never have a tent where all of the plants are at the end where they really smell. I do this so I only have to harvest a plant a week. I couldnt imagine trimming even half the tent at one time. Most do it but I would hate trimming 2lbs by myself at one time.

[5cooby Doo]

I have~1600W Led. So Filter ---> Inline ---> Duct out.

Speed of Green was right on point then! (I appreciate the calculations by the way!)

So then I will look at around 8" range Can Filter. Great!

Repuk oh okay. That is a good point, on the climate control, humidity.


And I was seeing new Can Max Pro fan, that has different technology. (It works sort of like a dyson vacuum vs traditional centrifugal type) Supposed to be much more quiet and efficient. Have you guys heard of this one?

[repuk]

If you refer to Can-Fan Qmax, yes:

The most suitable (oversized) one would be the CAN Q-MAX AC FAN 200MM 8" 3 SPEEDS 686/943/1120 M3/HR

Each speed will be 403CFM, 555CFM and 660CFM, so probably 1st or second speed will be perfect for your scenario, taking into account it should produce more pressure than a standard one.

Bear in mind the size though, its shape resembles more a scrubber than a inline fan: a cylinder measuring 26" long and 8" diameter:



AFAIK Can products are comparable if not better than RVK/Sileo, never tried one of these but RVK/Sileo = top notch inlines.

[5cooby Doo]

Hmm, not that one, but that one looks very good to! I really like noise reducing foam they're using in that.

I was mentioning this one; https://canfilters.com/max-fantm-pro-...oip_country=CA

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CnE7ZIpsQP0&t=193s