[mushroombrew]

Originally Posted by DocTim420

Amen to the 10k finishing. There are 1k bulbs but I prefer using 600w for my UVb source, especially in my perpetual garden. IMO, the benefits are:

1. A pair of 600w has better coverage than a single 1000w lamp.
2. The 600w lamp must be closer to the plant canopy thus concentrating the UVb spectrum to the targeted plants--not the neighboring plants. If the UVb source was from 1000w then the lamp would higher and a greater number of unintended plants would receive UVb sooner than desired.
3. Price is cheap, compared to the alternatives. My electric panel can not handle the increase 600w to 1000w for two banks of lights, nor will the current AC setup. Hmmm, new sub-panel, new ballasts, new AC for what??--a constant battle to prevent plants from getting hit with UVb at the wrong time? Nahh, the 600w lamps work perfect for me; their perceived weaknesses work to my benefit.

BTW, my mostly organic custom peat blend garden pulls a harvest every week or so; each plant averages just over a 1/4 pound of manicured buds. So yeah, do investigate which specific light spectrum you want, when and how long; it works for me. Imo, it certainly is better than doing what most everyone else is doing: MH (4k Kelvin) for vegetative growth and HPS (2-3k Kelvin) for flower/fruiting growth.

What about a flip box? You can flower twice as much. And the AC remains adequate before only half the bulbs are on at once.

Check this out. Ran (4) 600W Horts over a 4x8. And the other trays were (2) 1000w horts. The 600's looked visibly more yellow. And buds did not get the density of the 1000 Watters.

Totally wierd. More watts more lumens less yield?? Color temp was different. And was running nice Lumatec digi's too so wasn't a ballast issue.

Well the 600's are long gone.

[Floridian]

I've never used 600W lamps but from I've read over the years and my experience it doesn't surprise me that 1 K horties will yield better in the end even if the wattage is slightly less than with the multiple 600's.What I don't get is why there is a visable color difference between the 600's and 1K's.Thats pretty weird what does it say in the literature about color and par watt difference between 600"s and 1K"s?I've lately been leaning more towards increasing color temperature and UVB light towards the end of flower these days when I start up again but I can't conceivably give up my 1K's except maybe for LED's

[mushroombrew]

Originally Posted by Floridian

I've never used 600W lamps but from I've read over the years and my experience it doesn't surprise me that 1 K horties will yield better in the end even if the wattage is slightly less than with the multiple 600's.What I don't get is why there is a visable color difference between the 600's and 1K's.Thats pretty weird what does it say in the literature about color and par watt difference between 600"s and 1K"s?I've lately been leaning more towards increasing color temperature and UVB light towards the end of flower these days when I start up again but I can't conceivably give up my 1K's except maybe for LED's

They are supposed to be identical spectrums. Same gases just a smaller arc tube.

But if I can see it with the naked eye they must be quite different.

Oh all the bulbs were new when I noticed. 600's had the color of a 1000W towards the end of warm up. As in burning cooler.

I should email Hortilux and see what they say. I got a bunch of 600's just sitting...gay.

[Floridian]

Well I can't speak as to the sexual preference of 600"s or 1K's for that matter lol,I'm sure some prefer the base and some the screwshell!

[DocTim420]

Originally Posted by mushroombrew

What about a flip box? You can flower twice as much. And the AC remains adequate before only half the bulbs are on at once.

Check this out. Ran (4) 600W Horts over a 4x8. And the other trays were (2) 1000w horts. The 600's looked visibly more yellow. And buds did not get the density of the 1000 Watters.

Totally wierd. More watts more lumens less yield?? Color temp was different. And was running nice Lumatec digi's too so wasn't a ballast issue.

Well the 600's are long gone.

Maybe I did not explain myself very well.

In my perpetual flower room, I have 4 zones: 1st zone is 600w MH 7.2k UVb, 2nd & 3rd zone are 1k HPS, and zone 4 is 600w MH 10k UVb. The objective is to bathe zones 1 & 4 with UVb while limiting exposure to the middle zones 2 & 3. By using a lower wattage UVb lamp, I am able to lower those lamps closer to the plant which also reduces the amount of UVb light spilling over to the plants sitting under HPS.

Just for the record, no density issues here...rock hard nugs all around.

I used to buy Horti 1k HPS and replaced them every 6 months. Then I decided to try Plantmax 1k bulbs and replace them every 3 months instead of 6. According to my light meter:

1. A brand new Plantmax has more lumens than a 3 month old Horti.
2. A 3 month old Plantmax has more lumens than a 6 month old Horti.
3. A brand new Horti has more lumens than a brand new Plantmax.
4. Horti has a slightly greater Kelven (2.1k vs 2k) than Plantmax.
5. Price for Horti is just under $80, price for Plantmax is just under $25.

https://www.1000bulbs.com/product/88101/PX-LU1000.html
https://www.1000bulbs.com/product/1796/LU1000S-HTL.html

[mushroombrew]

Originally Posted by DocTim420

Maybe I did not explain myself very well.

In my perpetual flower room, I have 4 zones: 1st zone is 600w MH 7.2k UVb, 2nd & 3rd zone are 1k HPS, and zone 4 is 600w MH 10k UVb. The objective is to bathe zones 1 & 4 with UVb while limiting exposure to the middle zones 2 & 3. By using a lower wattage UVb lamp, I am able to lower those lamps closer to the plant which also reduces the amount of UVb light spilling over to the plants sitting under HPS.

Just for the record, no density issues here...rock hard nugs all around.

I used to buy Horti 1k HPS and replaced them every 6 months. Then I decided to try Plantmax 1k bulbs and replace them every 3 months instead of 6. According to my light meter:

1. A brand new Plantmax has more lumens than a 3 month old Horti.
2. A 3 month old Plantmax has more lumens than a 6 month old Horti.
3. A brand new Horti has more lumens than a brand new Plantmax.
4. Horti has a slightly greater Kelven (2.1k vs 2k) than Plantmax.
5. Price for Horti is just under $80, price for Plantmax is just under $25.

https://www.1000bulbs.com/product/88101/PX-LU1000.html
https://www.1000bulbs.com/product/1796/LU1000S-HTL.html

Will look into plantmax. Spend grands on bulbs so I like the idea.
Recently dumped T5's for 600 MH becuse the T5's cost way more to relamp.

[DocTim420]

Do try em. If you want, do what I did and run some lamps with Horti and others with Plantmax. At harvest, I saw no difference in the bud's quality/quantity. And that was what? 3-4 years ago when I changed over. I do know this...at 6 months, you can see the difference between a Horti & Plantmax--but Horti starts out of the gate with an extra 5k lumens or so.

I just placed my quarterly order with 1000bulbs.com and they have great customer service. Last year I had a 1000w bulb that had a tiny piece of glass rattling inside the globe--although it did not affect the operation, they replaced it free.

[mushroombrew]

Originally Posted by DocTim420

Do try em. If you want, do what I did and run some lamps with Horti and others with Plantmax. At harvest, I saw no difference in the bud's quality/quantity. And that was what? 3-4 years ago when I changed over. I do know this...at 6 months, you can see the difference between a Horti & Plantmax--but Horti starts out of the gate with an extra 5k lumens or so.

I just placed my quarterly order with 1000bulbs.com and they have great customer service. Last year I had a 1000w bulb that had a tiny piece of glass rattling inside the globe--although it did not affect the operation, they replaced it free.

The horts will have higher lumens. But if you relamp with plantmax every 3 months you're mean lumens probably stay higher overall?
Great now I really need that lux meter ! haha

[DocTim420]

Originally Posted by mushroombrew

The horts will have higher lumens. But if you relamp with plantmax every 3 months you're mean lumens probably stay higher overall?
Great now I really need that lux meter ! haha

That is what my light meter says.

If the cost of 1 Horti is $75 (rounded) and the cost of 1 Plantmax is $25...I guess you could replace the Plantmax bulbs every 2 months and still spend the same (assuming the replacement cycle for Horti's are 6 months).

Look at the this graph--


Notice the decline in both HPS & MH at 1000 hours (83 1/3 days at 12 hours per day). Six months at 12 hours per day equates to 2190 hours.

Bear in mind, as your lumens & PAR decline with hourly usage, your actual electricity usage will remain the same (no discount). So, imo...if I replace my bulbs more often than every 6 months, then the ratio of my lumens to kilowatts should be more efficient. In other words, why spend the same amount in electricity if the amount of lumens/PAR you receive each month is rapidly declining?

[Speed of green]

+1 on the plantmax - For the price i think they hold their own. change mine every 2 grows.