What's new

Lumens, lux and Lumateks

I've been running a 600 C.A.P. magnetic ballast in my flower room w/ a 90 day old bulb. Yesterday I picked up a used Lumatek 750 watt HPS ballast and swapped it in for the C.A.P. (I dialed down the output to 600 watts first). Just for giggles, I measured the output from the bulb with my light meter under identical conditions so I could see if there was a significant difference between the two ballasts. What followed shocked me:

C.A.P. 320
Lumatek 600

That is a *huge* difference in output, but what was even stranger was that to my naked eye, there was absolutely no difference in brightness or spectrum. The C.A.P. is only a year old, so I can't believe the capacitor has started to die. I'm going to grab another 600 watt magnetic ballast for further testing.

What I'm more interested in is the inability to see the difference. I've used dimmable ballasts before, and it is very obvious when you dial down the wattage, so a 100% increase in output should be easy to see. Since my light meter measures lux, not PAR, it should theoretically be seeing things the same way my eyes see it, although not necessarily the same as my plants.

Thoughts? Theories?
 

whazzup

Member
Veteran
I would also test your mains voltage. A magnetic ballast will output less when the input voltage is lower than specified. An electronic ballast has a stable output over its input voltage range. At a lower voltage it will use more amps and be a bit less efficient (so probably a bit warmer than usual).

Some ballasts have a soft-dim feature, which takes 60 seconds per step. Even id you go down to 50% your eyes don't see a difference during the complete adjustment phase while the meter keeps counting down.

So if you are not able to immediately compare such high outputs I don't think you would never see the difference. Your eyes register it as "a lot of light" :D.
 

whazzup

Member
Veteran
In fact then the magnetic ballast would have to give a bit more light than the Lumatek at 100% with 243V ;)

So indeed, either not wired correctly or defect.
 

Latest posts

Latest posts

Top