What's new

Jury nullification in Montana!

Storm Crow

Active member
Veteran
Potential Montana Jurors Stage ‘Mutiny’ in Pot Case

By Associated Press , 12-19-10
MISSOULA – Potential jurors staged a "mutiny" during a felony drug case, a Missoula County prosecutor says, and authorities worry the result will be viewed as a game-changer when it comes to future attempts at prosecuting drug cases in Montana.

Nearly all 27 Missoula County residents during the jury selection process on Thursday told District Court Judge Dusty Deschamps there was no way they would convict anybody of having a couple of buds of marijuana.

"I thought, 'Geez, I don't know if we can seat a jury,'" said Deschamps, who called a recess.

The case involved Touray Cornell, whose criminal history includes numerous felony convictions and in his latest case faced a felony charge of criminal distribution of dangerous drugs.

That charge stemmed from an April 23 search of his home following complaints from neighbors he was selling drugs. Police said they found burnt marijuana cigarettes, a pipe and some residue.

An affidavit said Cornell admitted to distributing small amounts of marijuana and connecting other dealers with customers, getting small amounts of marijuana for himself as payment.

At the time of his arrest Cornell was out on bail on a charge of felony conspiracy to commit theft, of which he was convicted in August.

During the recess called by Deschamps on Thursday, Deputy Missoula County Attorney Andrew Paul worked out a plea agreement with the defense.

"A mutiny," Paul told the Missoulian in describing the actions of the potential jurors.

"Bizarre," said Cornell's defense attorney, Martin Elison.

(snipped)


http://www.flatheadbeacon.com/artic...ontana_jurors_stage_mutiny_in_pot_case/21094/

He ended up taking a deal which got him 1 year in jail with 200 days of credit for time served. Jury nullification is a good thing!

POWER TO THE PEOPLE!
 

Sam the Caveman

Good'n Greasy
Veteran
I don't get it, why did he take a plea deal knowing that the jury would not convict?

If the trial ended with the jury entering their "not guilty" judgement, then why did he have to take a plea deal, he should have been free to go.

Ok, just read that they conned him into an Alford plea, which means he admitted that there was factual evidence of criminal conduct.

If only he would have kept his mouth shut, he wouldn't have had to serve any time at all.
 
Yeah sounds to me his lawyer was a real dick head..... and he got a year suspended sentence for that? BOO! Really cool the citizens stood up for pot.... I like that part of the story...
 

Sam the Caveman

Good'n Greasy
Veteran
not quite Vikingtrich, he got sentenced to 30 years with 29 suspended and one to serve. they did apply the 200 days already served towards his 1 year, how nice of them.
 

keyplay

Active member
ICMag Donor
yeah, the felony conspiracy ....theft charge definitely indicates higher intelligence. But WTF! you think they may have had it out for the guy?

30 years????? thats RED
 

toastfighter2

Active member
Where is this place, because I for one do not want to go there-I walk around everyday with more than what he got caught with just in my pockets.
 

David762

Member
This is the ultimate way to fight for what's right.

This is the ultimate way to fight for what's right.

Potential Montana Jurors Stage ‘Mutiny’ in Pot Case

By Associated Press , 12-19-10
MISSOULA – Potential jurors staged a "mutiny" during a felony drug case, a Missoula County prosecutor says, and authorities worry the result will be viewed as a game-changer when it comes to future attempts at prosecuting drug cases in Montana.

Nearly all 27 Missoula County residents during the jury selection process on Thursday told District Court Judge Dusty Deschamps there was no way they would convict anybody of having a couple of buds of marijuana.

"I thought, 'Geez, I don't know if we can seat a jury,'" said Deschamps, who called a recess.

The case involved Touray Cornell, whose criminal history includes numerous felony convictions and in his latest case faced a felony charge of criminal distribution of dangerous drugs.

He ended up taking a deal which got him 1 year in jail with 200 days of credit for time served. Jury nullification is a good thing!

POWER TO THE PEOPLE!

Until collectively our voices are heard at the ballot box, jury nullification is the only viable way to fight the draconian police state laws used to persecute non-violent victimless drug crimes. Our politicians (most of them, anyway) have been bought off by the fascistic crony corporations that actually run this country.

I personally vow that if I'm ever put on a jury for such a crime, I will always vote to dismiss the charges. And if I somehow find myself in such a position as a defendant, to always seek a jury trial.
 

One Love 731

Senior Member
Veteran
Sounds to me like he shouldn't have took the deal. Nice to see people in Montana are using there heads, now if we can get the rest of the world to follow. Peace, pot and karma. One Love:ying:
 

Stress_test

I'm always here when I'm not someplace else
Veteran
I don't get it, why did he take a plea deal knowing that the jury would not convict?

If the trial ended with the jury entering their "not guilty" judgement, then why did he have to take a plea deal, he should have been free to go.

Ok, just read that they conned him into an Alford plea, which means he admitted that there was factual evidence of criminal conduct.

If only he would have kept his mouth shut, he wouldn't have had to serve any time at all.

I think some of you folks misread the article.
"Jury nullification" means that a jury finds a defendant innocent because the law itself is unjust, or is unjust in a particular application, and so should not be applied. Jury nullification can also happen when a jury basically refuses to try a case because every jury member believes that the charges being brought are frivolous and should not even be a crime.
 
C

CANNATOPIA

Nice Read & post friend. Its Always good to read things like this.
 

Sam the Caveman

Good'n Greasy
Veteran
Jury nullification can also happen when a jury basically refuses to try a case because every jury member believes that the charges being brought are frivolous and should not even be a crime.

I didn't know they had the opportunity to do that, refuse to try a case. That sounds like what happened here.
 

paladin420

FACILITATOR
Veteran
Jury nullification

Jury nullification

I didn't know they had the opportunity to do that, refuse to try a case. That sounds like what happened here.
My lawyer just pointed out that jury nullification was a large factor in repealling prohibition on acholol.Once a jury desides it's over. Lawyers and judges can't point it out to juries....WE CAN.... 63% of Michigan voted yes to Medical MJ
 

Sam the Caveman

Good'n Greasy
Veteran
yes, I understand jury nullification, but they got him on what they call an "alford plea" which is why he got sentenced.
 
G

greenmatter

yes, I understand jury nullification, but they got him on what they call an "alford plea" which is why he got sentenced.


exactly .... lesson is help your lawyer out by not saying or signing ANYTHING !!!!! EVER !!!!!
 

Deft

Get two birds stoned at once
Veteran
I was offered a sweet plea deal after the cop who gave me a very big ticket for doing well more than double the limit forgot the road it happened on and had no record if it... The traffic judge was not amused and let him know it.

They do this when they know their chance of winning goes out the window.
 

Latest posts

Latest posts

Top