What's new

Is it inhuman to kill a seriously mained/dying animal?

I think you did the right thing. As unfortunate as it is to have to kill the animal, in a situation like that it would be the logical thing to do.

Here's a story that might make you feel a little bit better: last weekend I was driving through an isolated back road. It was out in the middle of nowhere. There were woods running alongside the road, and there were perhaps 3 houses in about a 5 mile radius of the area I was in. As I drove around a sharp bend, a big scruffy-looking dog ran out from the woods and in front of my car. I slapped the brakes on and slowed to a stop. The dog came trotting up to the car, looked at me for a second, then sprinted off in the direction I had just come from. I had a look up the road and into the woods and I couldn't see anyone walking the animal, so I turned the car around and drove after it. I caught up with the dog after about a minute, and stopped the car. I opened the door and tempted the dog towards the car. It wagged its tail and ran over to me. It absolutely stank, and it was emaciated. Its fur was all matted, and I could feel almost every bone in its body as I stroked it. It had obviously been living rough for a while. It had a docked tail too, but was a friendly animal that responded appropriately when I told it to sit, so I assume that at some point it must have had an owner.

I patted the back seat of the car and the dog hopped in quite willingly. It laid down on the back seat of my car and went straight to sleep. I think it was completely exhausted. As the dog was sleeping, I drove to the local houses and asked the owners if it belonged to any of them. They all said no, so I started ringing the RSPCA and the dog warden to ask what to do. As it was 10pm on a Saturday night, they were pretty much useless, so I decided to take the dog back to my house.

When I got the dog home, I grabbed a big can of Chump dog food, a dinner plate, and a bowl of water, and lead her up to the garden shed. I laid the food out on the plate and set it down on the floor. The dog ate all of the food in about 30 seconds and licked the plate completely clean. She then started looking for more food, but my understanding was that starving animals can sometimes eat more than their system can handle, and it can actually be detrimental to their health, so I didn't give it any more food. Instead I laid out a bed for her in the garden shed and shut her in there for the night.

The next day I took some more food to the dog which was eaten equally as fast. The dog was extremely friendly, and didn't show a hint of aggression. She was also very playful. She started following me around loyally and wagging her tail whenever my attention was focused on her. I got out an old children's paddling pool and filled it up about 6 inches with water. She walked over to it, jumped over the side of the pool into the water, laid on her side, and rolled over onto her back. She did this a few times, giving herself a good wash. Now that she'd been given a good rest, plenty of food, and a good wash, I decided to ring a local shelter and see if they could do anything for the animal. They arranged to meet me locally to pick the dog up, and said that the dog would be given a good wash, some food, a check-over from a vet, and would then be re-homed. So now, that smelly, starved, and exhausted dog I found out in the middle of nowhere is being fed and well looked after, and should be going to a loving family fairly soon.

So if it's of any comfort to you, you can remember this: although you had to end the life of that kitten to prevent it from suffering any more, another animal was given the chance to have a good life.

Here's some pictures of the dog too, for anyone interested:

http://i31.tinypic.com/25547ew.jpg

http://i27.tinypic.com/9pz3b5.jpg

http://i25.tinypic.com/2a0n6hc.jpg
 

armedoldhippy

Well-known member
Veteran
it normally sucks to do the right thing. i have put down 2 deer that were hit & thrashing around, but i hunt them as well. they tasted exactly like the ones i shot from my tree stand with my bow...it is a moral coward that would dis you for doing what you did. i watched a young man get hit by a car & flung into the ditch a few years ago, right in front of my house. the crowd of assholes that gathered was like nothing i have ever seen. i checked for pulse (fluttering wildly) & tried to get his head/neck into better position to help him breathe. (he died before ambulance got there, massive internal injuries) these fools were hollering at me "you'll get sued!" "i wouldn't do that if i was you!" etc. i hope someone like me comes along if i ever get injured...
 

Hash Zeppelin

Ski Bum Rodeo Clown
Premium user
ICMag Donor
Veteran
I feel sorry for you. no one should be forced to do something that hard when it wasnt their fault. and those people should have been ashamed of them self's for saying mean stuff to you as if it wasn't hard already.

plus it is even harder with domestic animals. they are bred to be our friends and we are raised to love them. a little baby kitten is just a cute and lovable as a little baby human.

Dont feel guilty. you did right by the poor thing. otherwise it would have stayed there until it died of it's wounds or other animals eating it while it was still alive.

the person who should feel guilty is the lady who hit it and did nothing. she should have taken to the closest vet or done it her self.

that lady was a coward and you were not.
 
iwas put in the same kinda situation i had to shoot a friends boxer after he was hit it was so hard for me to pull the trigger but i did due to the agony and pain this dog was suffering not counting this is my 2nd fav breed of dog ... i felt the emotions u felt for weeks and it still stays in my mind but i know it was what was best for the dog
 
A

arcticsun

I have been in the same situation, I live in a place with many animals and much wildlife. In fact ive grown up learning the respectful way to take an animal life.


The way you have to think about it, is that you have to recognize that the animal world is different then the modern human world. An animal that is hurt does not have a social structure to take care of it. Hospitals and such. The natural way or natures way to deal with a hurt animal is to kill it and if possible eat it. That is why we have predators, their sole job in life is to hunt down and take out hurt and sick animals.


Be proud of yourself that you are able to be so mindfully empathic towards an animal, that you acted in the correct way. That animal would most likely have died by getting mauled by another animal because it would have been unable to defend itself, it may even have starved and suffered to death.


You did the right thing, its natural to feel guilty and conscious about it, but you can feel at ease with that you did the right thing. It looks and feels horrible, but often doing the right thing does not feel good at all.
 

LiLWaynE

I Feel Good
ICMag Donor
Veteran
MAN i would NEVER be able to do such a thing.... i guess i am a coward.... But i do believe that it is the proper thing to do to a suffering creature...

but seriously though, how crazy would it have been to see the lady run it over, then get out of the car, and snap its neck...
 

PoopyTeaBags

State Liscensed Care Giver/Patient, Assistant Trai
Veteran
honostly yes you did the right thing... Very hard desicion the people that said your goign to hell are cowards it takes courage to do the right thing and hurts inside but you know it was right
 

Brother Bear

Simple kynd of man
ICMag Donor
Veteran
:respect: Fuck man you got me crying with that one :comfort: Damn
Well i know it's hard as hell, but i think you also did the right thing.
Rest well tonight knowing what you did was the right thing, read all the positive posts my friend.
One day let's hope them *college thug types* find their hearts too, i was one an ignorant young man too...
 
T

Tr33

it's hard, but it needs to be done sometimes. most city urban folk just do not understand this fact. a few do, but not the mass mind. You can see by the reactions in these posts.

I live in, and grew up in a rural environment where we take care of our own in any way needed to survive. Not everyone has the luxury of living this way, and I don't think most people could live a self sufficient life style, no matter how hard they try, we still need the urban city to survive in this messed up country.

what was done needed to be done in all humane ways possible as it was.
 
Thanks for the rep message Brother Bear.:thank you:

I rang the shelter that's currently looking after the dog last Thursday. They told me that as soon as the dog got there they gave it a good wash and a haircut, and have been feeding it 3 large meals a day. Apparently it's putting on weight very quickly. They also had it checked over by a vet, and the vet's conclusion was that the animal was in perfect health (aside from the odd scratch and being very underweight.)

They also commented that the dog is wonderfully well behaved and friendly and in their experience will be re-homed very quickly. I'll be sure to get updated on it.

Unfortunately it's not realistic for me to take on the animal myself (though I'd love to, as it was such a friendly and playful animal), but I'm asking around for people that could take it on. Although I only had the dog for a single night, I feel kind of attached to it. I'd like to be able to go and see it once in a while.
 
u def did the right thing. had to do something similair to a dog of mine that had gotten shot twice with a 12ga for chasing the neighbors horses. very hard to do but was def the right thing to do. and i agree city folks for the most part are just not taught these kinds of things and would just walk right past the poor kitty. kudos to u
 

crazybear

Member
A quick and painless death is good for all...including humans. How civilized are we? We euthanize a dog but won't a man? Better to suffer for days...weeks...months...? I don't think so.

:yeahthats
I totally agree, years ago we had to put our dog down, had him for 14 years, I knew it was the right thing to do.
I believe that Oregon is the only state that has compassionate care like if you have a condition that your going to die from you can decide how you want to go. Why should our fury friends be the only ones that don't have to suffer?
 

BagseedSamurai

Active member
Yes, it is considered "inhuman" because it is considered a cold act. That, however, does not mean that an animal with no chance of survival except a few brief minutes or hours in excruciating pain deserves to live out the rest of that pain.

In the end, killing can be compassionate, I think. Morals are just a chemical reaction anyway.
 
B

Ben Tokin

The OP can still have a farm and not have to kill animals. Just grow grains and vegetables.....oh yes, and herbs!

But he's definitely gonna go to HELL :hotbounce for killing that poor little kitten! :sasmokin:
 
Old name for this was "Mercy Killing". I had to do it a few times on the farm, and it's never enjoyable, but it is the right thing to do.
If I was in the kitten's situation you could put me out of my misery.
 

Miss Blunted

Resident Bongtender
Veteran
God I hate these fucking threads....I have 5 cats. Yes, you did the right thing....just hard to read this. You were brave, don't feel bad. The kitten was suffering....I'm sorry you were put in that position. The woman that left it there is a sick bitch. Even if she couldn't end it's suffering herself, she could have taken an hour out of her day and taken it to be euthenized....no excuses for her. God help that bitch.
 

darko_G

Member
i do beleive you have some support matey... vet wouldhave done the same but a couple hours later. been there and done it is bolloz killing something but these things have to be done
 

igrowkushbitch

Active member
you did the right thing. sucks it had to be a cute little cat but you took the high road. most people would of just drove away.
 

Latest posts

Latest posts

Top